| Message |
Details |
Quoting ObiKen:
Quote:
Quoting Nosferatu:
Quote:
... Even so, an edition would be unnecessary because there is no need to distinguish this from other releases of the same name, nor to indicate that this is a special release of this title.
Doesn't the rules for edition also specify collections?, namely:
"The Edition field is for distinguishing between DVDs, and for indicating special versions and collections (for example The Criterion Collection, Widescreen, Full-Screen Edition, Director's Cut)."
My understanding is "3-Movie Collection" complies with the edition rule and it is no different to other valid editions such as "Double Feature" or "Triple Feature" and it also tells us there are three DIFFERENT movies in the box set, which adds significant value to the cover titles, particularly when two titles are exactly the same.
I wouldn't argue against its inclusion, but it does seem to be superfluous because the title includes three different films, so the 3-Movie Collection aspect is self-explanatory.
That said, the wording does feature very prominently on the cover and there is at least one precedent for including that edition in my collection: The Blues Brothers / National Lampoon's Animal House / Stripes: 3 Film Box Set (EAN 5050582792867). | Posted: Topic Replies: 12, Topic Views: 6210 |
 |
The rules are very clear: "Use the title from the front cover."
Even with editions, they say "Edition is generally displayed on the front, but may also be gathered from the back cover if present." There is no mention of the spine being used for editions. Even so, an edition would be unnecessary because there is no need to distinguish this from other releases of the same name, nor to indicate that this is a special release of this title.
Going by the rules, I think the official title should be "The Thing / The Thing from Another World / The Thing" without an edition, but I would have the locked title as "The Thing 3-Movie Collection" in my local database. | Posted: Topic Replies: 12, Topic Views: 6210 |
|
Quoting Addicted2DVD:
Quote:
Not in the case of features. Features is seldomly even close to being the same. But yes there is a lot of things that will be the same making it worth cloning and updating all the differences.
There will be similarities and differences between the Criterion Blu-ray and DVD releases of the same film on the same date – some releases will be almost identical across the formats and others will not – but they are probably close enough to make the 'clone and adapt' approach the quickest way to make an accurate DVD profile from scratch. | Posted: Topic Replies: 7, Topic Views: 4324 |
|
| The Wistful Widow of Wagon Gap – Jimmie Bates | Posted: Topic Replies: 5, Topic Views: 3209 |
|
Father Knows Best: Season Five – Jimmy Bates (episodes 4, 15, 19, 23, 33, 35 & 38)
Father Knows Best: Season Six – Jimmy Bates (episode 2) | Posted: Topic Replies: 5, Topic Views: 3209 |
|
Easter Parade – no credit
Singin' in the Rain – no credit
Father Knows Best: Season One – Jimmy Bates (episode 16)
Father Knows Best: Season Two – Jimmie Bates (episode 12)
Father Knows Best: Season Two – Jimmy Bates (episodes 17, 21 & 23)
Father Knows Best: Season Three – Jimmy Bates (episode 27)
Father Knows Best: Season Four – Jimmy Bates (episodes 4, 7 & 25) | Posted: Topic Replies: 5, Topic Views: 3209 |
|
If the UPC doesn't exist, then it makes sense to take the Blu-ray release of that title and change the UPC to the one on the DVD packaging.
The DVD will probably have the same features, cast, crew, release date, studios, media companies etc., so it would just be a case of adding the cover images, aspect ratio, disc info, audio tracks, and other data that is specific to the DVD.
It's that or adding the DVD as a barebones profile and copying and pasting the pertinent data from the Blu-ray profile. | Posted: Topic Replies: 7, Topic Views: 4324 |
|
The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air: Season Three
Episodes 1, 3, 4, 6 & 8
Costume Designer: Violette Jones-Faison
Key Costumers: Melissa Franz and Loring Spicer | Posted: Topic Replies: 7, Topic Views: 4379 |
|
The Locket – Joe Melody (sound supervisor)
Loving Leah – Joe Melody (sound supervisor) | Posted: Topic Replies: 56, Topic Views: 13829 |
|
| Smallville: Season Seven – Robert New (Director of Photography) | Posted: Topic Replies: 5, Topic Views: 5244 |
|
Quoting Kathy:
Quote:
Quoting reybr:
Quote:
Michael White (1936)
Producer (Monty Python and the Holy Grail)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_White_%28producer%29
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0925214/
Michael White (1962)
Production Designer (The Rock, Alien 3)
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0925214/
Michael White (1954): Composer, Musician, Score Mixing, Performer, Actor:
Composer:
- Manufacturing Dessent
- Sway
- The Frank Truth
- Invisicible City
Musician/Actor
- Liberty Street Blues
- Tune in Tomorrow
http://www.nytimes.com/movies/person/1280161/Michael-White
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1821610/reference
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xlw2my_maroon-zarico-liberty-street-blues_music
http://www.nytimes.com/movies/movie/349294/Liberty-Street-Blues/details
Michael White (????), Actor
– Body Double
– Cagney & Lacey
– Murder, She Wrote
– Saved by the Bell: The New Class
– The New Women
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0925223 | Posted: Topic Replies: 5753, Topic Views: 373967 |
|
| A Woman Called Moses – James Sikking (as MC CRACKEN in Part One) | Posted: Topic Replies: 63, Topic Views: 16438 |
|
| The Dirty Dozen: Next Mission – Morgan Sheppard (as German General) | Posted: Topic Replies: 29, Topic Views: 13076 |
|
| The Elephant Man – Morgan Sheppard (as MAN IN PUB) | Posted: Topic Replies: 29, Topic Views: 13076 |
|
| Doctor Who: Series 6 – William Morgan Sheppard (Old Canton Delaware in Episode 1 and Canton Delaware in Episode 13) | Posted: Topic Replies: 29, Topic Views: 13076 |
|
The Legend of Frosty The Snowman – VERNEE WATSON JOHNSON (as Mrs. Wader)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EAyRjklUXQ&ab_channel=Weliketvthemes | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 11492 |
|
| Highland Park (aka Lucky Numbers) – VERNEE WATSON as May | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 11492 |
|
| Fresh Off the Boat: Series 1 – VERNEE WATSON as mrs. parker (episode 11) | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 11492 |
|