is this consider to be a box set?

Seems like if your using watched statistics like I do it would be easier for these types of movies, someone would then know what version of Dawn of the Dead Ultimate your watching or the extended Superman or Theatrical. Dont you agree?

I'm not too sure about this one - what you have is two films made by two different directors. The fact that they share some of the same shots shouldn't really matter.
I'd go for boxset - we've made other profiles into boxsets with a lot less justification!

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting northbloke:

Quote:
I'm not too sure about this one - what you have is two films made by two different directors. The fact that they share some of the same shots shouldn't really matter.
I'd go for boxset - we've made other profiles into boxsets with a lot less justification!

I agree.

I agree as well.

Quoting Katatonia:

Quote:
Some of the disc IDs are the exact same as the discs in the 14-disc Superman "Ultimate Collector's Edition" Box Set however ... so if this becomes a box set as well, which coverscans and case type are technically correct?

They both came out on the same release date, so either is technically correct then? It's a conundrum.

Does not matter to me, which ever are entered first would be my educated guess.

Quoting Katatonia:

Quote:
Quoting pplchamp:

Quote:
Does not matter to me, which ever are entered first would be my educated guess.

The "Ultimate Collector's Edition" was submitted/approved on here first. I don't know if that's valid enough to vote no on a submitted change however...

Sounds like users would play ping-pong ... not good

Quoting Mike:

Quote:
yeah Im seeing that in my contribution, to me its two differant box sets and I guess if Im going to be rejected Ill just have to lock my local database with the coverart and profile for my boxset.Seems wierd theyd release the exact same features ect with the same disc id.

Not weird at all... they release all five films separately, so that people can choose only to buy a selection of those. For those people who want it all they used the same discs, added a couple of diswcs as well, threw them all in one big packaging and sell  it as Ultimate Collection. why make different discs...

Quoting JaLe:

Quote:
I would say that even there is two little thiner than regular keep cases, it is still "Keep Case with Slip Cover"

And Superman movie doesn't have two directors. Old theatrical and new extended is directed by Richard Donner.
Superman II is different case.

You're right - my apologies - I was thinking of Superman 2 when I wrote that! In that case, I'm changing my stance - I don't think this should be a boxset.