In the Online database there are disc-level profiles (by Disc ID) for the "24" TV series. They have Overviews apparently taken from the booklet.  There are profiles also for the Special Features discs (disc @7)  in Season Two and in Season Three. The S.2 Special Features  disc has an Overview apparently taken from the booklet as well. On the contrary, the S.3 Special Feature disc's Overview is now empty.
Thus, I contributed an Overview for that disc, taking it from the booklet (actually I had to sum it up and contribute just the headlines, as the booklet also has long details on each deleted scene). But the Overview rule just says:

Quote:
When there is no overview on the case, add a simple, self-written overview of 1-2 paragraphs.

and that's what I did.
To my surprise, I got 4 No votes with the following reasons:
1."This is indeed not an overview"
2."Special Features belong in the Special Features section."
3."Special Features belong in the Special Features section."
4."as they said"

Could you please help me understand what I did wrong?

Edit: Here is the Overview text I contributed for 24:S.3:d.7 (S.3 Special Features disc)

Quote:

Special Features:

Three Featurettes
Multi-Angle Scene Study
Deleted/Extended Scenes: 45 Segments

and here is the Overwiew already in the online database for 24:S.2:d7 (S.2 Special Features disc):

Quote:

Special Features
45 Deleted Scenes with commentaries
Multi-angle scene study: A scene from episode 6, The Interrogation
Two-part documentary "24 Exposed" totalling 96 minutes
Featurette "On the Button - The Destruction of CTU"
Episode commentaries from cast and crew including Kiefer Sutherland, Dennis Haysbert, Sarah Wynter, Sarah Clarke, Xander Berkeley, Penny Johnson Jerald, Michelle Forbes, Joel Surnow, Bob Cochran, Jon Casser and Howard Gordon.

I have to admit.. I would probably have to vote no to such a thing too... Special Features do not go into the overview... that much is in the rules.

Now should there be an exception for special feature discs?... that I don't know. but as of right now there isn't one... and the fact that there is a profile/profiles in it don't mean that it is ok... just means that  per the rules those profiles are wrong.

Profiles for separate Bonus discs that are for a whole season or a Boxset of films are allowed by the rules. If there is an overview on the bonus discs case or the booklet, I would include it, as we include overviews in profiles. But if it's just a list of what's on the bonus disc, much like we see a list of special features on the back of any DVD, I would not include those as we don't include them as part of the overview in any profile.

Looking at my 24 season sets, it looks like what you put should be fine to me. Here's what the Bonus Features discs Overviews are for seasons 2-5

Season 2:
- All 44 deleted scenes with optional commentary by Jon Cassar and Rodney Charters (22 scenes), and Jon Cassar and Howard Gordon (22 scenes)
- "'24' Exposed" production featurette
- "'24' Exposed" post-production featurette
- Explosive behind-the-scenes featurette, "On the Button," detailing the filming of the terrorist bombing of CTU
- Multi-angle scene study (interrogation scene) from 1:00 PM - 2:00 PM

Season 3
- All 45 deleted scenes with optional commentary by Jon Cassar (16 scenes), Michael Loceff (6 scenes) and Howard Gordon (22 scenes)
- "'24': On the Loose" featurette
- "Boys and Their Toys" featurette
- "Biothreat: Beyond the Series" featurette
- Multi-angle study: Episode 12 "Midnight Shootout"

Season 4
- 39 deleted/extended scenes with optional commentary by Jon Cassar
- Exclusive Season 5 prequel bridging seasons 4 and 5
- Season 4 prequel
- Fox Movie Channel presents Making a Scene
- "Breaking Ground: Building the New CTU" featurette
- "Blood on the Tracks" featurette
- "Lock and Load" featurette
- "24: Conspiracy" cell phone mobisodes
- "The Longest Day" music video
- DVD-ROM link to "24: The Game" demo

Season 5
SPECIAL FEATURES INCLUDE:
- Season 6 Prequel
- 'Supporting Players' featurette
- 'Unsung Heroes: 24 Camera Department' featurette
- 'Music by Sean Callery' featurette
- 'Logan's Retreat' featurette
- '100th Episode Reel' featurette
- '24: Behind the Scenes' book sample
- Extended and Deleted Scenes with Optional Commentary by Stephen Kronish and Scott Powell
- Includes DVD-ROM Link to Access More Exclusive Content Online

I withdrew my Special feature disc Overview contribution. After reading this thread, Addicted2DVD in particular, I am not convinced it was right in the first place.