Since more and more 1080p 3D Blu-ray release are available, I thought it might be interesting to have the option to add two video scores to a review:
- regular video
- 3D video

Sometimes there can be a markable difference in quality. We could make it so that the option to have the video scores split is selectable, meaning for reviews there are three possible settings to choose from instead of just one:
- simplified score
- full score (movie, video, audio, extra's)
- fulle score 3D (movie, video, video 3D, audio, extra's)

What do other users think? A worthwhile addition?

Quoting Eagle:

Quote:
While this isn't something I would use, mainly since I don't have a 3D setup, I could certainly see the benefit of a separate 3D video rating. Take a look at Jaws 3 for example, the visual effects on the 2D version are down-right horrible, but way back in the day when it was originally in 3D, the wasn't nearly as bad (yes, I actually remember seeing this in 3D in the theater.    ). Since this is rumored to be in the works for a 3D BD release this August, a split video rating would come in very handy.

Awesome! I never had a chance to see this in 3D in theaters, so I'm looking forward to getting the 3D Blu-ray (as well as my future 3D setup, which I still need to buy  )

I've seen that some review sites like Blu-ray.com have also been using a dual review system for video quality: one for 2D, one for 3D and depending on the release, the score can be quite different. Some have great 2D and horrible 3D, others have both great or both horrible or even the other way around.

+1 for the video versions.

I did see it in the theater in 3D and it had it's moments. Believe it or not, my wife and I just watched it last night. The 2D is horrible. You can tell every part that was a showcase for 3D because it has a halo around it. A lot of the shots when viewed in 2D have double images in the forground and/or background. It does detract from the viewing pleasure. I always remember noticing it before, but since the new 1080p LED/LCD TVs, it's worse.